Pros and cons of shingles, tile and metal roofs

The Pros and Cons of Shingle, Tile, and Metal Roofs

Posted on February 22, 2023 by baker-admin

If you are in the market for a new roof, it can be an overwhelming task to decide on the type of roofing material that best fits your needs and budget. After all, there is a wide selection of roofing materials available- shingle and asphalt tile roofs, metal roofs, slate tiles, wood shakes, and more – each with its own unique advantages relative to factors like energy efficiency, cost-effectiveness, and lifespan. To help you choose which option is right for you so that your home’s exterior looks attractive while also achieving its intended protection against the elements., We will walk through some of the pros and cons associated with three common types of residential roofs: asphalt shingle roofs, metal roofs, and clay or concrete tiles.

Shingle Roofs

Are you thinking of replacing your roof and considering a shingle roof? While shingles are one of the most popular types of roofs among homeowners, it’s important to understand the pros and cons before making your decision. This blog post will help give you an overview of all the factors to consider when deciding whether or not a shingle roof is right for your home. We’ll look at everything from cost and durability to installation, maintenance, and design options. So read on if you’re looking for more information about this popular type of residential roofing!

The Pros of Shingle Roofs

Modern roofing and decoration of chimneys. Flexible bitumen or slate shingles in rectangular shape in perspective.

Asphalt shingles are widely popular for their endless benefits when it comes to roofing. These shingles are classified in a variety of classes, up to Class IV, which offer great protection from even the toughest weather conditions and elements. Not only are asphalt shingle roofs highly durable and affordable, but some types are also energy efficient, providing excellent insulation from both heat and cold. As asphalt shingles can be customized in look and color, they offer a classic aesthetic that matches well with any home or building – making asphalt roofs an ideal choice for an aesthetically pleasing and low-maintenance roof system.

The Cons of Shingle Roofs

One of the major cons of shingle roofs is degradation. Shingles are not extremely long-lasting, and they often need to be replaced after a decade or two. Depending on weather conditions, age, and maintenance needs, this degradation can happen sooner or later. Another downside is that shingle roofs tend to lack in visual appeal. Many people consider them to be plain looking compared to other roofing options, so your home may look less attractive than if you had used something else. Degradation and plain looks are two possible issues with shingle roofs that should be considered before installation.

Tile Roofs

clay tile roof If you’re in the process of thinking about roofing options for your home, one of the choices you may come across is a tile roof. Tile roofs are an attractive and classic option that can add beauty and value to any home, but there are also some downsides that should be considered before making a decision. In this blog post, we’ll break down the pros and cons of tile roofs so that homeowners can make an informed decision on whether or not it’s right for their property.

The Pros of Tile Roofs

Tile roofs offer a number of advantages over other traditional roofing materials. Tile is highly durable, with clay and concrete tile lasting for decades, even in extreme weather conditions. For areas that experience high winds, clay, and concrete tiles are rated with a Class IV rating and are able to withstand hurricane-force gusts. In addition, clay and concrete tiles come in a wide range of styles and profiles, allowing homeowners the ability to customize their home’s appearance while still reaping the many benefits of tile roofs. Last but not least, clay tile roofs come in an array of colors, making it easy to complement your home’s unique design or create something entirely new.

The Cons of Tile Roofs

Tile roofs are a beautiful choice for many homeowners, but they can also be expensive and burdensome. One of the most significant drawbacks to tile roofs is weight. Tile roofing made from concrete or clay weighs significantly more than other roofing materials, such as asphalt shingles, and may require reinforcing existing roof supports before installation. Additionally, concrete tile can fade over time and is prone to cracking in areas that experience freeze/thaw cycles. Replacing broken tiles or re-painting faded colors can help maintain aesthetic appeal on tile roofs but does add additional expense to their upkeep.

Metal Roofs

Metal gray roof with rhythmic parallel relief directions

Are you considering a metal roof for your home renovation? Before making up your mind, it’s important to weigh the pros and cons of installing a metal roof. From material type and lifespan to cost considerations, understanding all aspects before taking on this kind of project is key. In this blog post, we will explore the advantages and drawbacks of having a metal roof on your home so that homeowners can make an informed decision about their next major construction undertaking. Read on to learn more!

The Pros of Metal Roofs

Metal roofs have been increasing in popularity these days due to their many benefits. Standing seam metal roofs are a great choice for those who want a durable and elegant roofing solution. Stone-coated steel roofs offer even more protection against extreme weather conditions while also being pleasing to the eye with a variety of beautiful colors and styles. Many metal roofs are fire-resistant and have also been shown to be energy efficient thanks to the way they reflect heat away from your home. Additionally, their lightweight construction helps reduce installation costs and allows for easy repair or replacement if needed. With all these advantages, it’s no wonder why metal roofs continue to be such a sought after choice for homeowners!

The Cons of Metal Roofs

Even though metal roofs have long been hailed for their unbeatable longevity, increased energy efficiency, and top-of-the-line fire resistance rating, they have a few cons that sadly cannot be ignored. One issue that metal roofs are known to suffer from is oil canning – the phenomenon in which metal sheets form slight undulations on the surface due to uneven temperatures on the panel. Another less obvious con to many people is the fact that metal exclusion policies in home insurance policies are, more often than not, a reality when metal roofs are installed. Lastly, cosmetic waivers may prove costly when your home is struck with hail large enough to dent the panel but not penetrate. A cosmetic waiver may mean that your roof will not be covered by your insurance if the damage is deemed only “cosmetic.” While these points should not dissuade someone from investing in a metal roof entirely, it’s important to know what to learn more about and to weigh all of the pros and cons before making this big decision.

Making the Decision on a Roof

In summary, each roofing material has its own pros and cons. Shingles last up to 25 years and require little maintenance aside from some occasional debris removal, but they can be fragile in areas with heavy snowfall or extreme temperatures. Tile roofs are extremely durable, unique in their appearance, and can last for up to 50 years. The cost is one of the major drawbacks; tiles are steadily increasing in price, which can make them financially prohibitive for many homeowners. Metal roofs are lightweight, energy efficient, fireproof, and very strong. Although initial installation costs can be high, the fact that metal roofs typically have a lifespan of 40 years or more makes them a great long-term investment. Ultimately, it all comes down to your budget and needs when deciding which material is best suited for your Dallas home. If you’ve taken the time to research and still need help choosing between these three types of roofing materials, our experienced team at Baker Roofing and Construction are five-star roofing specialists and are here to help – just give us a call!

Back to Blog